Extension/Research Information

2002 Ohio Forage Performance Trials

Ohio State University Extension
Ohio Agricultural Research and Development Center
The Ohio State University

Horticulture and Crop Science
Series 195
November 2002


     Alfalfa has the highest combined yield and quality potential of any adapted perennial forage grown in Ohio. It is the state's largest single hay crop, being grown on about one-half of the total hay acres. Alfalfa requires well-drained soils with near-neutral pH (6.5-7.0) for greatest production and persistence. Alfalfa trials are initiated each year and data is collected for at least four years unless the stand becomes so depleted that further testing is no longer worthwhile; variety performance should be evaluated over several sites and years.

Guidelines for Selecting Alfalfa Varieties

    To capitalize on alfalfa's potential, select high-yielding varieties with resistance to problem diseases. Consider these factors when selecting alfalfa varieties for Ohio:

1. Yield. Yield is the major factor in determining profitability of an alfalfa stand. Select varieties with high yields over several locations and years. Table 3 shows this comparison in percent of the average yield. Varieties that perform equally well across several locations and years are probably adapted to a wider range of environmental conditions. Stable yield performance across several environments is important because soils may vary on your farm and weather conditions vary from year to year. Conditions on most farms are such that several varieties may perform equally well.

2. Persistence. Another important consideration beyond yield is how long the stand will last. Study variety performance by age of stand to get an estimate of longevity of stand productivity. Some varieties may decline with age more rapidly than others. This may influence your choice of variety depending on how long you intend to keep the stand in production. For long-term rotations, choose varieties with good performance in the fourth or fifth year of production. If you plan to harvest alfalfa for three years or less, then high performance during early years of the stand should be given major consideration.

3. Fall dormancy (FD) Alfalfa varieties with fall dormancy ratings of 1 through 5 are considered adequately winter hardy for Ohio conditions while those of 6 or higher are not considered adapted. Varieties with higher fall dormancy ratings tend to grow at a lower temperature. Thus they begin to grow earlier in the spring and later into the fall, extending the growing season. Until recently it was generally felt that fall dormancy rating was very closely correlated with winter hardiness. This relationship with modern varieties seems less dependable. Now, for example, a variety with a "2" dormancy rating may not always have greater winter hardiness compared to one with "3" fall dormancy rating. Fall dormancy ratings provided by the seed industry are given in Table 1.

4. Disease and pest resistance. Variety selection based on yield performance alone is less satisfactory than selections that also consider disease resistance characteristics. Resistance to specific disease-causing pathogens may be the most important attribute in an alfalfa variety. Pathogens can dramatically reduce yield and persistence of susceptible varieties. For example, Phytophthora root rot resistance is often very important on soils that are less than well-drained. The disease resistance characteristics of alfalfa varieties included in this report and their local seed marketers are listed in Table 1. Below is an explanation of the information found in Table 1.

a. Bacterial Wilt (Bw) and Fusarium Wilt (Fw) Nearly all alfalfa varieties currently grown in Ohio have resistance to Bacterial Wilt and Fusarium Wilt. The widespread use of these varieties has greatly diminished the significance of these diseases. However, severe losses can still be incurred in stands of susceptible varieties.

b. Verticillium Wilt (Vw) First detected in Ohio in 1984, this disease still has limited distribution within the state, having been confirmed on 17 farms in 9 Ohio counties. It has been found in Ashland, Columbiana, Franklin, Holmes, Knox, Logan, Medina, Stark, and Wayne Counties. Verticillium Wilt is usually introduced into a field on infested seed and generally does not become a problem until the third production year. Scattered plants become yellow and stunted and gradually die, leaving a thin, unproductive stand.    

c. Anthracnose (An) Anthracnose occurs during hot, rainy weather. The fungus attacks individual stems and grows into the crown, causing a crown rot and eventual death of the plant. Severe losses can occur the second and third year after seeding in stands of susceptible varieties.

d. Phytophthora Root Rot (PRR) This disease typically occurs in heavy or poorly drained soils. However, when any soil becomes water saturated, the fungus may invade the taproot and destroy the plant. Even resistant varieties are fairly susceptible to Phytophthora in the seedling stage.

e. Root Knot Nematode (RKN) Damage from Root Knot Nematode is most likely to occur on sandy or organic (muck) soils. Small galls or 'knots' form on roots. These may be confused with nitrogen-fixing Rhizobium nodules.

f. Aphanomyces root rot (APH) may contribute to poor alfalfa establishment and reduced growth in wet soils. Seedlings may die (damping off) if infection occurs at an early stage of development. Older seedlings are yellowed and stunted. When aphanomyces and phytophthora occur together, they form a destructive disease complex.

5. Compare to check variety. For comparisons of varieties across several trials, always compare varieties to the same check planted within the trial. The variety Vernal is used as a check in all Ohio trials.

6. Use good management. No variety can produce well under poor management. Good management considers all aspects of alfalfa production: seed bed preparation, liming and fertilization, seeding, pest control, harvest, storage, and post harvest treatment. Many newer varieties are better adapted to intensive management.

Table 1: Characteristics of Alfalfa Varieties Listed in This Report.

***Ratings were supplied by the seed industry and were not verified by university testing.***

The abbreviations for the column headings are: (FD) Fall Dormancy; (Bw) Bacterial Wilt; (Vw) Verticillium Wilt; (Fw) Fusarium Wilt; (An) Anthracnose; (PRR) Phytophthora Root Rot; (RKN) Root Knot Nematode; (APH) Aphanomyces Root Rot Race 1.

Resistance Key: 0-5% = susceptible (S); 6-14% = low resistance (LR); 15-30% = moderate resistance (MR); 31-50% = resistance (R); >50% = high resistance (HR). If the resistance rating for a variety is not listed, then the variety is susceptible or has not been adequately tested.

VarietyMarketer FD BW VW FW AN PRR RKN APH
4375LHMycogen Seeds4HRRHRHRHR--HR
6310Garst Seed 3HRHRHRHRHR--R
6420Garst Seed 4HRRHRRHR--R
A 30-06PGI Alfalfa Inc.3HRHRHRHRHR--HR
A-395PGI Alfalfa Inc.3HRRHRHRHR--R
Abt 350AgroBiotech3HRHRHRHRHR--HR
AceProvico Inc.4HRRHRHRHR--R
Affinity + ZAmerica's Alfalfa4HRHRHRHRHR--R
AlfaStarSteyer Seeds4HRRHRHRHR--R
Amerigraze 401+ZAmerica's Alfalfa4HRRHRHRHR--R
Ameriguard 301America's Alfalfa3HRRHRHRHR--R
AmeriGuard 302+ZAmericas Alfalfa3HRHRHRHRHR--HR
Ameristand 403TAmericas Alfalfa4HRHRHRHRHR--HR
ArrestNovartis Seeds3RHRHRHRHR--R
AwesomeL.G. Seeds4HRHRHRHRHR--HR
CompleteBird Hybrids3HRHRHRHRHR--R
Depend + EVAgriPro4HRHRHRHRHR--R
DKA 37-20Monsanto4HRHRHRHRHR--R
DKA 42-15Monsanto 4HRHRHRHRHR--HR
Feast EVGarst Seed Co.
FK 421Donley Seeds4HRHRHRHRHR--HR
FQ 302 HRMycogen Seeds3HRRHRHRHR--R
FQ 314Mycogen Seeds3HRHRHRHRHR--HR
FQ 315Mycogen Seeds3HRRHRHRHR--HR
GenevaNovartis Seed4HRHRHRHRHR--HR
GH 744Golden Harvest
GH 788Golden Harvest3HRRHRHRHR--HR
GH 794Golden Harvest4HRRHRHRHR--R
Green FeastBecks hybrid3HRHRHRHRHR--HR
Green FieldBecks Hybrids 3HRRHRHRHR--R
HayGrazerTMK Farm Service4HRRHRRR--MR
HyTest-410HYTEST Seeds
Innovator + ZAmerica's Alfalfa3HRRHRHRHR--R
MaconAllied Seed4HRHRHRHRHR--HR
Magnum III Dairyland4RMRRMRR--LR
Magnum VDairyland4HRRHRRHR--MR
MainstayAg Venture3HRHRHRHRHR--R
Multi-PlierMycogen Seeds3HRRHRHRHR----
OvationL.G. Seeds4HRHRHRHRHR--R
PersistDoebler’s Hybrid Inc4HRRHRRHR--MR
PhirstDoebler’s Hybrid Inc4HRRHRHRHR--HR
PrecedentDoebler’s Hybrid Inc4HRRRRHR--R
PredatorDoebler’s Hybrid Inc.3HRRHRHRHR--HR
PristineDoebler’s Hybrid Inc.4HRRHRHRHR--R
Reward IIPGI Alfalfa Inc.4HRRHRRHR--R
SafeGuard Allied Seed3HRRHRHRHR--R
StarbuckSeeds Ohio4HRRHRHRHR--HR
SynergyCrows Hybrids3HRRHRHRHR--HR
TMF 4355LH Mycogen Seeds3HRRHRHRHR--R
TMF Mutiplier IIMycogen Seeds3HRHRHRHRHR--R
WinterGoldBeck’s Superior Hybrids4HRHRHRHRHR--HR
WL 232HQRoyster-Clark 2HRHRHRHRHR--HR
WL 319 HQRoyster-Clark
WL 325 HQ Royster-Clark3HRRHRHRHR--R
WL 327Royster-Clark4HRRHRHRHR--HR
WL 338 SRRoyster-Clark4HRRHRHRHR--HR
YielderAgriPro Seeds3HRHRHRRHR--HR

Summary of 2002 Alfalfa Crop Conditions

    The year began with a late spring but good stands for most entries. Temperatures and rainfall were above normal in April, while temperatures were below normal in May with abundant rainfall. Rainfall in June through August varied widely across locations and temperatures were well above normal at all but Northwest. A new trial was seeded in April 2002 at Wooster, but stand establishment was poor due to heavy rains and soil crusting. Dry weather prevented planting in August. That trial will be seeded in April 2003. First harvest yields were average to high where alfalfa weevil infestations were controlled.

    Forage yields in 2002 were lower than those from 2001, except in the 2001 seeding at Western. Forage yields were highest at Northwest and Wooster, interesting because those two locations had the highest (28.8 inches) and lowest (14.3 inches) rainfall for April through August, respectively. Alfalfa weevil populations were high again this year and well above economic action thresholds at all locations in the spring. For more information on alfalfa weevil management see Ohio State University Extension Fact Sheet FC-ENT-32 (alfalfa weevil) available at the county extension office and on the internet (https://ohioline.osu.edu). Insecticide application was used at all locations for control. Potato leafhopper (PLH) control. Activity was low to moderate at North Baltimore, Wooster, and Jackson but was very high for the second and third harvests at S. Charleston. Insecticide applications were used to control PLH infestations in the standard sprayed trials (Tables 4-8) only. No insecticide was applied to control this pest for the potato leafhopper resistance trials (Tables 9-12). These trials are a continuing evaluation of the new glandular-haired alfalfa varieties that have improved resistance to potato leafhopper.

    Two new alfalfa trials were seeded in April 2002. One trial was established at S. Charleston (Table 12) to continue potato leafhopper resistance evaluations.


Table 2. Weather data summary for the 2001 growing season.

MonthColumbusWoosterS. CharlestonN. BaltimoreJackson
Precipitation (inches of rainfall)
Apr5.71.964.240.92 4.640.676.853.607.263.45
May10.225.843.990.08 6.321.737.934.494.880.72
June7.593.113.26-0.68 5.060.903.710.164.380.66
July2.70-1.960.86-3.24 7.463.385.361.575.810.80
Aug2.31-1.271.97-1.49 1.70-1.684.952.132.990.52
Total28.527.6814.32 -4.4125.185.0028.8011.9524.69 6.15
Average Daily Temperature (°F)
May59.0-2.455.9-2.6 58.1-3.255.6-1.259.5-2.2
June74.33.970.83.2 72.82.572.12.672.82.9
July78. 75.71.976.
Aug76.23.673.03.0 73.41.470.4-
*DFA = departure from longterm average

Table of Contents